Self-tanning used to terrify me until I realized the secret isn’t the product — it’s the prep. Here’s the routine that gives you that natural-looking glow without looking orange.
— — —
Self-tanning has a reputation for being either impossible or looking like you got dipped in an orange vat. Neither of those things has to be true. I used to be genuinely terrified of self-tanner — I’d heard too many horror stories about streaks and uneven color and weird dark spots. But then I realized everyone who had disasters didn’t prep properly. Once I actually did the steps, it became so easy I do it monthly now.
The difference between a beautiful natural glow and looking like an oompa loompa is literally just exfoliation and moisturizing in the right spots first. That’s it. Here’s the full routine:
Step 1: Exfoliate everything (this is the secret)
1. Tree Hut Shea Sugar Scrub
~$12 on Amazon
Use the same scrub from your body care routine. Apply in the shower 24 hours before you tan (not the day of). Focus on rough areas like elbows, knees, ankles, heels — these areas have dead skin that tan grabs onto and turns dark. If you skip exfoliation this is where you’ll get those weird dark patches that look nothing like the rest of your tan.
2. Exfoliating Mitt
~$8 on Amazon
Do a second gentle exfoliation with the mitt the morning of tanning. This removes any last-minute dead skin without irritating. It’s a cheap tool that genuinely changes the outcome.
TIMING TIP Exfoliate 24 hours before tanning, not the day of. Your skin needs a tiny bit of time to settle so the tan grabs evenly. Same-day exfoliation + tanning = patchy results.
Step 2: Moisturize the right way
This is where most people mess up. You can’t just skip moisturizer on tanning day — you need to be strategic about it.
After exfoliating, moisturize everywhere EXCEPT where you want the deepest color. So: moisturize your face, neck, underarms, inside of thighs, and anywhere that gets friction (like where your bra sits). Do NOT moisturize: elbows, knees, ankles, tops of feet, hands. Those drier areas need the tanner to adhere more so they match the rest of your body.
Step 3: Apply the tanner
3. Isle of Paradise Self-Tanning Drops
~$20 on Amazon
Add these to your regular body lotion and mix. This is the absolute easiest way to start because you control the strength — add more drops for a darker tan, fewer for a light glow. No streaks, super forgiving, and it looks natural because you’re literally mixing it into lotion. Perfect for beginners.
4. Tanning Mitt Applicator
~$10 on Amazon
Do NOT use your hands to apply. Your palms will turn dark orange and it’s impossible to fix. The mitt is literally a $10 solution to a $200 problem. Use it everywhere except your face, neck, and hands.
Apply in upward strokes, thin layers, and work quickly. Don’t overthink placement — just blend as you go. If you use drops mixed with lotion it’s super hard to mess up because you’re working with product you already know how to use.
Step 4: Face & hands separately
Your face needs lighter tanner than your body or it looks dirty. Either use a gradual self-tanner on your face only, or dilute your tanner more with lotion. For hands, either don’t tan them at all or use the mitt to apply the tiniest amount to the tops only — skip your palms entirely.
Step 5: Aftercare (this makes it last)
5. Tan-Extending Lotion
~$22 on Amazon
Apply this every single day after your tan develops. It keeps your skin hydrated so the tan fades evenly instead of getting blotchy. A hydrated tan lasts way longer — we’re talking 2 weeks instead of 5 days of looking decent.
6. Setting Powder for Face
~$12 on Amazon
If you tanned your face, set it with powder after 6 hours so it doesn’t transfer onto pillows or rub off on your phone. Just a light dusting is enough.
WAIT TIME Don’t shower for at least 6-8 hours after applying tanner. The longer you wait, the deeper the color develops. Sleep in it if you can and shower the next morning.
— — —
Common mistakes (and how to fix them)
Dark elbows, knees, ankles: You didn’t exfoliate enough. Next time, use the scrub AND the mitt, and avoid moisturizing those areas.
Streaky application: You applied too much product at once. Use the mitt next time and do thin layers instead of trying to cover everything in one pass.
Orange hands: You touched your face or body after applying. Hands need the mitt too or they’ll turn into orange gloves.
Patchy fading: You didn’t moisturize after tanning. Start using tan-extending lotion immediately and the next tan will last way longer.
When to use gradual vs. one-time tanner
For beginners, I recommend starting with gradual self-tanner or the drops method because there’s no pressure — you can build color slowly and you have time to fix mistakes. Once you’re comfortable, the one-time application tanning lotions work great and give you instant results. But for your first time? Gradual all the way.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. All opinions are my own.